Abstract
This paper presents a techno-economic comparison between two plant configurations, respectively based on recuperative thermal oxidizers (TO) and regenerative thermal oxidizers (RTO), analysing their operating principles, energy performance and key design parameters, with particular focus on heat recovery aspects, utilities and reagents consumption, operational flexibility and integration with auxiliary treatment such as neutralization units for halogenated compounds (e.g. quenchers/scrubbers packages). The work also includes the analysis of a real application case in the chemical-pharmaceutical sector, concerning the treatment of gas streams containing VOCs with both hydrocarbon and halogenated matrix, in which both technological solutions were evaluated through thermo-fluid dynamic simulations and cost models based on realistic operating conditions. The comparison allows to quantify the differences, particularly in terms of specific fuel consumption, annual operating costs, payback time, and impact on the plant life cycle. The results show that the selection of the optimal configuration cannot be separated from an integrated analysis of the physic-chemical characteristics of the gas streams, the specific operating conditions, and the relevant process parameters. In this context, the availability of both technologies and the ability to assess their applicability through a systemic engineering approach represent a key factor for optimizing the environmental and energy performance of industrial plants.